'Uncharted Territory' With High Water
Temps Around Florida (Source: New York Times)
Florida’s coral reefs are facing what could be an unprecedented threat
from a marine heat wave that is warming the Gulf of Mexico, pushing
water temperatures into the 90s Fahrenheit. The biggest concern for
coral isn’t just the current sea surface temperatures in the Florida
Keys, even though they are the hottest on record. The daily average
surface temperature off the Keys on Monday was just over 90 degrees
Fahrenheit, or 32.4 Celsius, according to NOAA. The real worry,
scientists say, is that it’s only July. Corals typically experience the
most heat stress in August and September.
“We’re entering uncharted territories,” Derek Manzello, an ecologist
and the coordinator of NOAA’s Coral Reef Watch program, said. Oceans
have absorbed some 90 percent of the additional heat caused by humans
as we burn fossil fuels and destroy forests. When sea temperatures rise
too high, corals bleach, expelling the algae they need for sustenance.
If waters don’t cool quickly enough, or if bleaching events happen in
close succession, the corals die. For decades, scientists have been
warning that climate change is an existential threat to coral reefs.
Already, the world has lost a huge proportion of its coral reefs,
perhaps half since 1950. (7/12)
Artemis 4 and Artemis 5 Moon Missions
Will Include European Astronauts (Source: Space.com)
We now know when Europeans will land on the moon alongside NASA
astronauts. Both the Artemis 4 and Artemis 5 moon-landing missions,
which are slated to launch in 2028 and 2029, respectively, will feature
one European Space Agency astronaut, ESA Director Josef Aschbacher told
Space.com. Another ESA astronaut is guaranteed to fly on a future
Artemis moon mission, but which one is not decided yet. (7/12)
SDA Plans Procurement of Fire Control
System for Missile Tracking Constellation (Source: GovCon Daily)
The Space Development Agency is seeking industry feedback on a draft
solicitation for a procurement effort to build the fire-control segment
of the Proliferated Warfighter Space Architecture system. A notice
posted Friday on SAM.gov states that the Fire-control On
Orbit-support-to-the-war Fighter program will comprise eight prototype
satellites equipped with electro-optical/infrared sensors. (7/11)
NASA Accepts New Astrovans for Artemis
Missions (Source: CollectSpace)
NASA has taken delivery of next-generation "astrovans" for future
Artemis missions. The agency received three electric vans from Canoo
Technologies that will be used to take astronauts to the launch pad for
Artemis missions. Canoo won the contract to provide the vehicles, based
on an existing commercial design, in 2022. They replace larger vans
that had been used by Apollo and shuttle crews. The Apollo and space
shuttle-era vans are now on display at the Kennedy Space Center Visitor
Complex, in the Apollo/Saturn V Center and Space Shuttle Atlantis
exhibit, respectively. (7/12)
JWST Celebrates First Year
(Source: NASA)
NASA is marking the first anniversary of the first public science
images from the James Webb Space Telescope with another image. NASA
released this morning a colorful image of a star-forming region in the
Rho Ophiuchi cloud complex, the closest star-forming region to the
Earth at a distance of 390 light-years. Some of the stars visible in
the cloud show dark regions that are likely protoplanetary disks, or
solar systems in the process of formation. (7/12)
China Launches Methane-Fueled Zhuque-2
Rocket to Orbit (Source: Space News)
A Chinese company became the first to reach space with a methane-fueled
rocket late Tuesday. The company's second Zhuque-2 rocket lifted off at
9 p.m. Eastern from the Jiuquan Satellite Launch Center. The rocket
reached orbit, although it carried no payloads. Zhuque-2 is the first
rocket that uses methane and liquid oxygen propellants to reach orbit,
beating Western vehicles like Relativity Space's Terran 1 and SpaceX's
Starship that suffered launch failures in the spring. The successful
launch also makes Landspace the second private Chinese launch firm to
reach orbit with a liquid propellant rocket after Space Pioneer and its
Tianlong-2 rocket in April. (7/12)
Here Come the Moon Landing Missions
(Probably) (Source: Ars Technica)
There have been three primary drivers of renewed interest in the Moon.
The first was the discovery and confirmation in the 1990s and early
2000s that water ice is likely to exist at the lunar poles in
permanently shadowed craters. The presence of abundant water, providing
oxygen and hydrogen resources, has given space agencies a new reason to
explore the poles. A second factor has been the rise of China's space
program, which has sent a series of ambitious robotic missions to the
Moon that have both landed on the far side and returned samples from
the lunar surface.
Finally, there has been some interest from private companies in the
commercial development of the lunar surface, both to exploit resources
there but also for other purposes. This has stimulated investment in
private companies to provide transportation to the lunar surface,
including ispace, Astrobotic, Intuitive Machines, and Firefly. The end
result of all of this is that we are about to see a flurry of missions
that will attempt to land on the Moon. During the last decade, dating
to China's Chang'e 3 lander in 2013, there have been six attempts to
land on the Moon; all were successful. Three other attempts, one backed
by Israel, another by India, and a third by a private Japanese company,
ispace, have failed to softly touch down on the Moon.
Now, in the next six months, as many as six more landing attempts may
come. Here's
a rundown of what to expect, and when to expect it. (7/11)
Russia’s Luna-25 Lunar Lander Arrives
At Vostochny Spaceport (Source: Aviation Week)
Russia is approaching the launch of its Luna-25 mission to the Moon—the
country’s first lunar exploration effort in almost 50 years. The
long-delayed 3,860-lb. spacecraft was finally delivered on July 11 to
Vostochny spaceport in the country’s Far East, according to Roscosmos
Space Corp. Before traveling there, it completed acceptance and
predelivery tests. At the spaceport, the lander will undergo final
preflight and ground checks and be mated with a Fregat booster before
lifting off atop the Soyuz-2.1b launch vehicle on Aug 11.
Russia will be competing with India to obtain samples of water ice on
the Moon, Russian space expert Vitaly Yegorov said. The Indian Space
Research Organization (ISRO) plans to launch its Chandrayaan-3 mission
to the Moon to explore lunar soil and rocks one month earlier–on July
14. But the Russian spacecraft has a chance to reach the Moon’s surface
before the Indian spacecraft, which will travel along a longer
trajectory and is expected to land on Aug. 23 or 24. Luna-25 is
expected to be followed by at least two other Russian missions to the
Moon: the Luna-26 orbiter and the heavier Luna-27 lander. (7/12)
Japan to Launch Lunar Lander in August
(Source: NHK)
Japan's space agency says its lunar lander will be launched on an H2A
rocket next month. The Japan Aerospace Exploration Agency, or JAXA, on
Tuesday announced the launch of the probe called the Smart Lander for
Investigating Moon, or SLIM. The SLIM project is seeking to be Japan's
first lunar landing. It will test pinpoint landing technology as well
as examining moon rocks. The H2A is to lift off from the Tanegashima
Space Center in southwestern Japan on August 26 at 9:34 a.m., local
time. The launch vehicle will also carry a new X-ray astronomical
satellite, XRISM, jointly developed with US space agency NASA and
others. (7/11)
Israel's SpaceIL Wrestles With Costs
for Lunar Mission (Source: Space News)
A second attempt by an Israeli organization to land a spacecraft on the
moon has an uncertain future. SpaceIL has been working on Beresheet 2,
which will feature two small landers and an orbiter and had been
scheduled for launch in 2025. However, donors who had been backing the
mission announced in May they would not provide any additional money
beyond the $45 million provided to date, less than half the mission's
projected cost. The chairman of the Israel Space Agency said at a
recent conference that work on the mission is continuing but noted that
they are still working on the funding problem. The original Beresheet
mission, also philanthropically funded, crashed attempting to land on
the moon in 2019. (7/12)
India Shoots for the Moon with Latest
Rocket Launch (Source: Space Daily)
India on Friday launches its latest attempt at an unmanned moon
landing, the next frontier of a burgeoning, cut-price aerospace
programme rapidly closing in on the milestones set by global
superpowers. If successful, the mission would make the world's most
populous nation only the fourth country after Russia, the United States
and China to achieve a controlled landing on the lunar surface.
The latest iteration of the Chandrayaan ("Mooncraft") programme comes
four years after an earlier attempt ended in failure, with ground crew
losing contact moments before landing. This time around, there is
optimism that the Indian Space Research Organisation (ISRO) will
succeed, as it sets its sights on a future manned lunar mission. (7/12)
ESA Unveils its New Events Venue in
the UK (Source: ESA)
A state-of-the-art conference centre that will support the thriving UK
space industry has opened at Harwell campus in Oxfordshire. Part of
ESA’s European Centre for Space Applications and Telecommunications
(ECSAT), the facility will serve as a rallying point for the UK space
community, reinforcing existing ties and fostering new partnerships
within Europe and beyond. It was opened as part of an event that
showcased ESA’s growing footprint in the UK and the strong cooperation
between the UK and the agency. (7/11)
NASA Decides Not to Launch Two
Already-Built Asteroid Probes (Source: Ars Technica)
Two small spacecraft should have now been cruising through the Solar
System, on their way to study unexplored asteroids, but after several
years of development and nearly $50 million, NASA announced the probes
will remain locked inside a Lockheed Martin factory in Colorado. That’s
because the mission, called Janus, was supposed to launch last year as
a piggyback payload on the same rocket with NASA’s much larger Psyche
spacecraft, which will fly to a 140-mile-wide metal-rich asteroid—also
named Psyche. Problems with software testing on the Psyche spacecraft
prompted NASA managers to delay the launch by more than a year.
An independent review board identified issues with the spacecraft’s
software and weaknesses in the plan to test the software before
Psyche’s launch. Digging deeper, the review panel determined that
NASA’s JPL, which manages the Psyche mission, was encumbered by
staffing and workforce problems exacerbated by the COVID-19 pandemic.
Psyche is now back on track for liftoff in October on a SpaceX Falcon
Heavy rocket, but Janus won’t be aboard.
While the Psyche mission can still reach its asteroid destination and
accomplish its science mission with a launch this year, the asteroids
targeted by Janus will have changed positions in the Solar System by
too much since last year. They are no longer accessible to the two
Janus spacecraft without flying too far from the Sun for their solar
arrays to generate sufficient power. Scientists considered other uses
for the suitcase-size Janus spacecraft, which were already built and
were weeks away from shipment to Florida to begin final launch
preparations when NASA decided to delay the launch of Psyche. (7/11)
Alabama Lawmaker Holds Up DoD Funding
Over Space Command (Source: The Gazette)
The Air Force is suspending some bonuses and putting some base
reassignments on hold, after an Alabama lawmaker blocked a routine
request from the Department of Defense to reallocate funds. U.S. Sen.
John Hickenlooper (D-CO) called out U.S. Rep. Mike Rogers (R-AL), the
chairman of the House Armed Services Committee, for blocking a routine
request for reallocation of funds across the Department of Defense to
force a decision on the permanent home for Space Command. The delay
that has already caused problems for the Air Force is "dangerous and
harmful," Hickenlooper said. (7/12)
U.S. Sharpens Plan for Military Space
Race (Source: Space News)
The latest U.S. military budget goes all-in on the notion that
resilience will be a core feature of space programs. As evidence, the
term surpasses 300 mentions in the Space Force’s 2024 budget documents.
The emphasis on resilience — or adaptability in the face of attacks —
reflects the priorities set by the new chief of space operations Gen.
Chance Saltzman. The running theme in the budget is the need to ensure
U.S. access to space and shore up capabilities to compete with space
powers like China and Russia. (7/11)
National Guard in Space? White House
Says No Thanks (Source: Space.com)
The office of United States President Joe Biden has voiced opposition
to the creation of a Space National Guard. Currently, the Army and the
Air Force have National Guard reserve components, but the U.S. Space
Force does not. Several lawmakers in Congress have previously proposed
the idea of creating a Space National Guard to provide part-time forces
to bolster Space Force personnel numbers. But the push has yet to
receive enough support to make it into law.
Now the White House has voiced its opposition. On Monday (July 10), the
Executive Office of the President of the United States issued a
statement that argues against the creation of a Space Force element of
the National Guard. "The Administration continues to strongly oppose
the creation of a Space National Guard," the White House's statement
reads, urging Congress "not to create a new bureaucracy with
far-reaching and enduring implications and expense." (7/11)
Will Aerojet/L3Harris Deal Mean More
Stingers, Javelins for Ukraine? (Source: Wall Street Journal)
How big is too big in defense? Lawmakers are wrestling with this
question as they consider whether a decadeslong wave of consolidation
has left the sector incapable of producing weapons fast enough to keep
up with demand stemming from the war in Ukraine. Sen. Elizabeth Warren
and three other lawmakers have asked the Pentagon to block L3Harris
Technologies' proposed $4.7 billion purchase of Aerojet, but L3Harris
claims the deal will speed the delivery of critical weapons to Ukraine
during its conflict with Russia. (7/11)
Guam Seeking to Expand Airport
Activities, Eyeing Space Flights (Source: Marianas Variety)
Seeking to tap economic opportunities in the aerospace industry, Lt.
Gov. Joshua Tenorio will make a push for Guam as a prime spot for
expanded aviation operations, including space flights. Tenorio will
make a pitch at the 2023 Aerospace States Association (ASA) Annual
Meeting and Policy Summit, which opens today in Boulder, Colorado.
In 2019, Guam banked on the Virgin Orbit’s announcement that the
island's civilian airport would be used as a launch site for the
company’s LauncherOne service. The plan, however, fell through as the
rocket company filed for bankruptcy this year. This time, the
administration is pinning its hopes on the proposed establishment of a
Space Force National Guard. Space Force units are being proposed for
seven states — Colorado, California, Hawaii, Alaska, New York, Ohio,
Florida — and Guam. (7/11)
As One Long Beach Space Firm Implodes,
Another Seizes an Opportunity (Source: Long Beach Business
Journal)
With the metaphorical ashes of Virgin Orbit’s collapse still smoking,
Rocket Lab has stepped up to further solidify its position as Long
Beach’s preeminent space company, buying up millions of dollars in
assets from the now-defunct firm that will allow for an expedited
expansion. Virgin Orbit filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy in April, days
after announcing it would lay off 675 employees because it failed to
secure additional funding. Most of those employees had already been on
unpaid leave for weeks. In late May, Virgin sold off over $35 million
in assets to various space firms up and down the West Coast, including
Rocket Lab and Vast here in Long Beach. (7/11)
Houston Spaceport Companies Land NASA
Contracts for Upcoming Artemis Mission (Source: Houston Business
Journal)
Ahead of NASA’s return to the moon, two space companies with a Houston
presence landed contracts from the space agency. Houston-based Axiom
Space secured an initial $5 million commitment that could grow to $142
million over four years to modify its Artemis III lunar spacesuit
design for spacewalking from the International Space Station.
Meanwhile, North Carolina-based Collins Aerospace, a division of
Virginia-based Raytheon Technologies, landed a $5 million contract to
modify its own spacesuit design for operating on the moon. Collins
opened its 120,000-square-foot Houston Spaceport facility in late 2022.
In addition to spacesuit-testing services, the building also includes a
10,000-square-foot incubator space that the company said would mainly
be controlled by the city of Houston for collaboration opportunities
between universities and tech startups. (7/11)
The Tantalizing, Lonely Search for
Alien Life (Source: New Republic)
Jaime Green is drawn to aliens because they represent the point at
which science and ordinary human imagination meet. For Green, the most
interesting question to ask about aliens isn’t where or whether or not
but what if? This question is at the heart of scientific inquiry just
as much as it’s at the heart of our dreams and nightmares. Because of
that, the search for aliens in outer space is, at the same time, a tour
through alien stories, from classic fictions like Sagan’s to the more
contemporary envisionings. In her telling, novels, short stories,
films, and TV shows about extraterrestrials resemble folktales: They
give us myths and archetypes that explain an unexplainable world to the
people who live in it. (7/11)
NASA's Starling Mission Sending Swarm
of Satellites Into Orbit (Source: Space Daily)
This July, NASA is sending a team of four six-unit (6U)-sized CubeSats
into orbit around Earth to see if they're able to cooperate on their
own, without real-time updates from mission control. While that kind of
autonomous cooperation may not sound too difficult for humans, this
team will be robotic - composed of small satellites to test out key
technologies for the future of deep space missions, where more complex
and autonomous spacecraft will be essential.
Once launched, the four CubeSats will fly in two different formations
to test several technologies paving the way towards a future where
swarms of satellites can cooperate to do science in deep space. This
mission, called Starling, will last at least six months, positioning
the spacecraft about 355 miles above Earth and spaced about 40 miles
apart. (7/12)
China Aerospace Foundation and
Asia-Pacific Space Cooperation Organization Sign Cooperation MOU
(Source: Space Daily)
The China Aerospace Foundation and the Asia-Pacific Space Cooperation
Organization have solidified their commitment to collaboration by
signing a memorandum of understanding (MOU) at the headquarters of the
Asia-Pacific Space Cooperation Organization. Li Guoping expressed the
intention to collaborate on scholarships and other initiatives, aiming
to create branded aerospace public welfare activities and infuse new
vitality into the healthy development of the Asia-Pacific Space
Cooperation Organization. (7/12)
ESO's Extremely Large Telescope is Now
Half Completed (Source: Space Daily)
The European Southern Observatory's Extremely Large Telescope (ESO's
ELT) is a revolutionary ground-based telescope that will have a
39-metre main mirror and will be the largest telescope in the world for
visible and infrared light: the world's biggest eye on the sky.
Construction of this technically complex project is advancing at a good
pace, with the ELT now surpassing the 50% complete milestone. The
telescope is located atop Cerro Armazones in Chile's Atacama Desert,
where engineers and construction workers are currently assembling the
structure of the telescope dome at a staggering pace. Visibly changing
each day, the steel structure will soon acquire the familiar round
shape typical of telescope domes. (7/12)
Defunct Wind Satellite Set for
Unprecedented 'Assisted' Reentry (Source: Gizmodo)
A mighty wind satellite has been losing altitude at a steady pace of
nearly one kilometer per day. ESA will attempt to guide the Aeolus
satellite on its way down to minimize risk of damage as its pieces hit
the ground. ESA will attempt a first-of-its-kind assisted reentry. Once
Aeolus reaches an altitude of 280 kilometers, the team will send a
series of commands to the satellite over a six-day period, using its
remaining fuel to guide it towards an optimal position for atmospheric
reentry. (7/11)
Astranis Offers GEO Broadband
Satellite for Philippines (Source: Space Intel Report)
Astranis will provide micro-GEO satellite to the Philippines to cover
4,000-5,000 sites in a services contract with Orbits Corp. and Filipino
ISP HTechCorp. The satellite will be launched in 2024. Philippines is
an enormous potential market for satcom connectivity but it hasn't
moved as fast as Indonesia. (7/11)
Help ESA Research Key Space-Based
Solar Power Challenges (Source: ESA)
Space-based solar power could provide Earth with clean and reliable
energy, 24 hours a day. As part of its SOLARIS initiative, ESA is
inviting researchers to help advance our knowledge of key aspects of
collecting solar power in space and wirelessly transmitting it to
Earth. Click here.
(7/11)
Florida-Based Redwire to Expand in
Indiana (Source: Redwire)
Jacksonville-based Redwire Corp. plans to open a new state-of-the-art
microgravity payload development facility with a mission operations
center at the Novaparke Innovation & Technology Campus in Floyd
County, Indiana, as the company looks to increase production of
critical technologies enabling human spaceflight missions and
commercial microgravity research and development in low-Earth orbit
(LEO).
The new 30,000 square foot facility will support increased demand from
commercial companies and academic researchers focused on improving
pharmaceutical drug development, optimizing disease treatments, and
enabling technologies essential for sustainable human spaceflight in
LEO and beyond. Construction is expected to begin in the fourth quarter
of this year. (7/11)
Blue Origin Rocket Engine Explodes
During Testing (Source: CNBC)
A Blue Origin rocket engine exploded during testing last month, CNBC
has learned, a destructive setback with potential ramifications for the
company’s customers as well as its own rocket. During a firing on June
30 at a West Texas facility of Jeff Bezos’ space company, a BE-4 engine
detonated about 10 seconds into the test, according to several people
familiar with the matter. Those people described having seen video of a
dramatic explosion that destroyed the engine and heavily damaged the
test stand infrastructure.
The people spoke to CNBC on the condition of anonymity to discuss
nonpublic matters. The engine that exploded was expected to finish
testing in July. It was then scheduled to ship to Blue Origin’s
customer United Launch Alliance for use on ULA’s second Vulcan rocket
launch, those people said. A Blue Origin spokesperson, in a statement
to CNBC on Tuesday, confirmed that the company “ran into an issue while
testing Vulcan’s Flight Engine 3.” (7/11)
Muon Wins Option to Monitor Ionosphere
for Space Force (Source: Space News)
Muon Space will deliver space weather data to the U.S. Space Force
under a $400,000 contract option announced July 11. Under the original
$2.8 million contract with Air Force Life Cycle Management Center
Weather Systems Branch and the Defense Innovation Unit awarded in 2022,
Muon will deliver terrestrial weather products to the Air Force 557th
Weather Wing from a space-based prototype microwave sensor. The option
directs Muon to also monitor the ionosphere for the U.S. Space Force
through September 2024. (7/11)
Space Force Juggles Roles as Warrior
and Protector of Space Environment (Source: Space News)
In an era of great power competition and increasing global reliance on
space-based assets, the U.S. military is trying to harmonize seemingly
competing demands for security and sustainability. As a branch of the
U.S. military, the Space Force is tasked with preparing for potential
conflicts. But its leaders frequently remind audiences that a shooting
war in space must be avoided in order to ensure the sustainability of
the domain.
U.S. Space Command is the Pentagon’s combatant command responsible for
space operations. “Space security is our problem, but it’s your
problem, too. It is everyone’s concern today,” the command’s deputy
chief, Lt. Gen. John Shaw, said. The U.S. faces threats to its assets
in orbit and needs to defend them, Shaw said, but space sustainability
is now a front-burner issue when planning military operations. Shaw
acknowledged that, for decades, the U.S. military conducted space
activities with little regard for how they polluted orbits with debris
that posed threats to existing and future space-based assets. (7/10)
Why Africans Must Go to Space
(Source: Gadget)
Africa’s first woman in space has called for regional and global
efforts to enable more Africans to participate in space exploration as
part of efforts to advance the continent’s socioeconomic
transformation. Sara Sabry, a young Egyptian astronaut and founder of
the Deep Space Initiative made the call last week during a panel
discussion at the Africa50 Infra Forum meeting held in Togo’s capital
Lomé. The topic of the panel was A Different View: Africa’s future
reimagined. (7/11)
Former NASA Astronaut to Advise Vast
on Commercial Space Station Efforts (Source: Space News)
Vast Space has brought in a former NASA astronaut and SpaceX official
to serve as an adviser for its plans to develop commercial space
stations. Vast announced July 11 that it has appointed Garrett Reisman
as a human spaceflight adviser. He will assist the company, which
announced plans in May to develop a single-module station called
Haven-1 as a precursor for future, larger space stations.
Reisman joined NASA’s astronaut corps in 1998 and spent three months on
the International Space Station in 2008 as part of the Expedition 16
and 17 crews, and another 12 days on the STS-132 shuttle mission to the
ISS in 2010. He retired from the astronaut corps in 2011 and worked for
SpaceX for several years in various capacities, including director of
space operations. He is currently a professor of astronautical
engineering at the University of Southern California. (7/11)
Why Military Space Matters (Source:
Joint Force Quarterly)
Militaries fight wars and, in times of peace, prepare for the next war.
How they prepare matters. Preparing for war can help prevent war from
breaking out. At the same time, militaries that prepare to fight the
last war often fail in the next. Over the past two-plus decades of
military operations, our nation’s ability to use outer space has not
been consequentially challenged or contested. An unintended byproduct
of that circumstance is we have unintentionally conditioned strategists
and national security professionals to assume the space advantage is
our birthright. Click here.
(7/11)
India’s Renewed Effort Toward Space
Preeminence (Source: Space News)
India’s recent technical and political activities have boosted the
state’s climb to space preeminence. In parallel to several successful
launches that showcase the state’s capabilities and flexibility,
political initiatives focus the bureaucracy and exhibit a strong vision
for India’s future in space. India’s domestic success empowers the
state to join and meaningfully participate in elite civil and
commercial partnerships, notably signing the Artemis Accords during
last month’s state visit to the United States.
The administration of Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi can reap the
maximum benefits from these and future partnerships by expanding this
approach to the space security sector, beginning by conveying its
vision for governing the intersection of commercial and military space
applications. Earlier this year, India issued its first national space
policy. This approach supports private capital’s access to the space
sector and simultaneously frees state institutions to focus on work
that is not financially attractive endeavors for most industry players,
like basic science and deep space exploration. This guidance has been
sorely lacking for India’s commercial space sector, which has suffered
from the government’s ill-defined regulatory framework. (7/11)
No comments:
Post a Comment